Tim and Ed by Ursula Dubosarsky
Ill. by Andrew Joyner. Penguin, 2014. ISBN 9780670074631
(Age: 3+) Highly recommended. Siblings, Twins, Similarities,
Difference, Independence. Twin koalas, Tim and Ed are the same. they
have the same faces, arms, legs and noses. They look at their father
and wonder why there is only one of him, and the ducks when there
are so many ducklings. When Tim falls into the pond he is pulled out
by Dad, and Ed jumps in as well. After a noisy bath time Dad tells
the boys that Auntie Pim is taking Ed to stay with her for one
night. Tim is rather dismayed but Dad says they will do lots
together. At each house, Tim is shown with Dad having a good time on
their bikes, while Ed is enjoying his stay with Auntie Pim, playing
trains. But at night when they go to bed, a little wistfulness
occurs, as Tim looks over at the empty bed in their bedroom, and Ed
looks sadly at his image in the mirror.
The following day when Ed returns, Auntie Pim says that she will
take Tim for an overnight stay next time. The three go down to the
pond again and see that the ducklings are no longer there. They have
grown up and flown away.
In four line stanzas, Dubosarsky tells her story of difference. Tim
and Ed may be the same, looking the same, but they are different
beings, and in this story they are growing up, like the ducklings,
soon to fly on their own, but with a strong family and sibling bond
behind them. This is a lovely story of difference, of accepting
difference and similarity, of a child's place in the family, of
growing up. With its wonderful vibrant illustrations, showing the
two being together, of doing all sorts of things together, then
staying apart for one night, Joyner ensures that the readership will
empathise with the two little boys and their developing
independence.
Fran Knight