This girl that girl by Charlotte Lance
Allen and Unwin, 2016. ISBN 9781760291709
(Age: 3+) Recommended. Difference. Neighbours. Families. Living next
door to each other, two girls cannot be more different. This girl is
neat and tidy, with neatly combed hair, tied up shoelaces and neat
clothes, while that girl has every which way hair, floaty clothing
with a cape and seems careless of which colours go with what. The
soft watercolour illustrations will attract the reader's attention
from the start as they turn the pages and take in the differences
shown. Over the page we see the sort of things each girl likes,
further underlining their differences. This girl likes to collect
plants to add to a scrapbook, hoovering up the scraps at the end of
her day, and is particular about setting the table, and often sits
in a corner and reads. That girl, on the other hand loves running
through the leaves, scattering them around, climbing onto a brick
wall and walking along the top, and eating worms. They could not be
more different. Over the next few pages we see their families and
their houses, marking their differences again, but now their fathers
seem the exact opposite of each girl. One dad is neat and tidy, the
other dressed in unusual clothes with wispy floating hair. Each dad
has attributes seemingly more aligned to the girl next door, not
their own daughter.
But when it comes to building a treehouse, despite all the
preparation on one side and the haphazard manner of building on the
other, both finished tree houses look exactly the same. Readers will
love comparing both girls and their fathers, comparing the
attributes of each of the people shown, comparing the preparation
each does to build the tree house with the final results. Readers
cannot help but see that despite outside appearances, we are all the
same.
Fran Knight