Then by Morris Gleitzman
Puffin, 2008. 13+
Gleitzman began the story of Felix in Once. This sequel sees
Felix and
Zelda, the six year old girl he befriended, continue their desperate
journey into Poland. Felix, aged ten is Jewish, while Zelda is the
orphaned child of Nazi parents. Both are alone, starving and terrified
and see and endure far more than any child should ever have to.
Fortunately they are rescued by Genia, a Polish woman who lives alone
on a small farm. Felix and Zelda befriend the pig and the chickens and
Leopold, Genia's beloved dog. She passes the children off as relatives
whose home and immediate family have been bombed. The children reach an
uneasy contentment, cemented by Genia's kindness and the imaginative
games they play.
However their safety is put at risk by children from the village and
adults too, always on the look out for anyone harbouring Jews. There
can only be one outcome - and throughout the book it is gathering
momentum until it hits the reader with devastating force.
I found this story even more harrowing than The Boy in The Striped
Pyjamas and The Book Thief. There is something about
Gleitzman's
depiction of the brave but naive children, coupled with the
relentless horrors they experience, that is almost too painful to read.
Gleitzman describes how Felix and Zelda stumble across a pit full of
dead Jewish children. Violence and fear are ever present as the Nazis
descend on the farm, taking the pig and chickens and killing the
family's beloved pet dog. But it is the ending that really distressed
me.
As a child I remember the profound effect that certain books had on me.
Sounder by William Armstrong gave me bad dreams for weeks, and
that
was
a walk in the park compared with Then. It is natural for adults to be
protective of children, but how far should we go? One of the strengths
of a book like Gleitzman's is that we can encounter Nazism vicariously,
experiencing it through Felix and Zelda, but how many of us want our
children to be faced with the full Nazi horror? Perhaps we should
proceed with caution, ensuring that this is a book that children share
with adults rather than read alone, so that we can talk about it with
them and absorb some of the horrors that real children just like Felix
and Zelda endured.
Claire Larson