The wrong boy by Suzy Zail
Black Dog Books, 2012. ISBN 978-1-742031-65-1.
(Ages: 14+) Four stars. In Suzy Zail's emotional narrative, The
Wrong Boy, Hanna Mendel is caught in the midst of the horrors
of the holocaust. This is Suzy Zail's first work of fiction for
young adults and from its opening page, the reader will feel empathy
and heartache for those who suffered during this violent era.
Hanna is a young Jewish teenage girl with aspirations for her
future. She has hopes of becoming a concert pianist, and is imbued
with excitement at the prospect of attending the Budapest
Conservatorium of Music. With such promise so close at hand, Hanna
can barely comprehend the impact that her family's incarceration in
the Debrecen ghetto, and ultimately their internment in
Auschwitz-Birkenau concentration camp is about to have on her life.
With moving clarity, Hannah's voice throughout reveals the stench
and raw agony of the cattle trains, the belching prison chimneys,
and her awakening to the plight of her family, as her father is
drawn away by the SS Guards, leaving her sister and mother to cope
alone. Finally with the branding A10573 on her arm, she knows her
life has changed forever. Hanna makes an opportunistic decision and
joins the Birkenau Women's Orchestra. Her actions have unexpected
consequences as she begins an unusual relationship.
This novel will be an excellent library and resource book. It will
help to open the conversation with young teenagers about this dark
side of modern history, and the atrocities borne by the Jewish
people during the Second World War. Suzy Zail has researched well
and draws extensively from her wide reading, and her father's first
hand accounts of his experiences during the holocaust.
Colleen Tuovinen