The Reluctant Hallelujah by Gabrielle Williams
Penguin, 2012. ISBN 9780143566847.
(Ages: 14+) In this review I am going to give away the big surprise
in the plot, so please stop reading if you don't want to know what
makes this novel controversial, and a risky choice for some school
libraries. Dodie Farnshaw is about to sit her final year
exams when her parents go missing in very mysterious circumstances.
One of her classmates, Enron, contacts her to say he can help, and
that there is a key in a sneaker belonging to her mother that will
unlock the mystery. When they investigate the basement they find the
well preserved body of Jesus in a coffin. As the baddies close in
Dodie, her sister Coco, and three assorted teenage boys take Jesus
on a road trip to save him.
The jokes around Jesus are quirky rather than offensive to me, but I
know others in my school community that would not see the humour at
all. The relationship between Dodie and her sister is believable and
appealing but the interest that Dodie shows in the character Jones
seems unrealistic, considering the peril they are in as they flee up
the coast. Williams writes well and her descriptions of the tunnels
of Melbourne, and the small towns Dodie and the other characters
find themselves in interesting, but the plot stretches credibility
to too great an extent for me.
Chris Lloyd