The Prague Cemetery by Umberto Eco
Vintage Books, 2012. ISBN 9780099555971.
(Age: 18+) Reading an Umberto Eco novel is always a rich and
challenging experience and this novel is no exception. However, it is
hard to see it appealing to many teen readers. This is partly due to
the style and structure of the work; set in the 19th century it reads
like a novel from this era with a 'Narrator' who addresses the reader
in a formal manner. It is partly due to the slow and rambling pace of
the work. It is partly because the novel is teeming with real life
historical figures, most of whom will be unfamiliar to teens, even
those who are keen on history. It is also partly due to the rather
unlikable nature of the main character who makes a living from
fraudulent dealings and who is stridently anti-Semitic. This stance may
well have the reader feeling uneasy and struggling to fathom whether
there is an element of intended irony at play.
On the design side, the novel is beautifully presented, with frequent
black and white sketches of the characters which not only complement
the story but also add to the 19th century feel of the work. Eco's
writing is always dense and full of intriguing ideas but this novel has
a decidedly slow-burn approach which may test the patience of readers.
Ultimately there is an adult feel and flavour to this novel which may
make it less appealing to teenagers, even the most mature of readers.
Deborah Marshall