The Lie Tree by Frances Hardinge
Macmillan, 2015. ISBN 9781447264101
(Age: 13+) Highly recommended. Mystery. Lies. Truth. Fantasy. Costa
Book Award for Children's Book (2015), Carnegie Medal Nominee
(2016), Costa Book of the Year (2015), YA Book Prize Nominee (2016).
When Faith's father is found dead at the bottom of a cliff, she is
determined to find out what has happened to him. Her mother and
uncle drag his body into the orchard, and Faith refuses to believe
that he has committed suicide. She reads his journals and finds
references to the Lie Tree that he has hidden in a cave, a tree that
feeds off lies and reveals hidden truths when lies are fed to it.
She begins to spread lies across the island and the truth begins to
appear.
Dark and demanding, this is not a book that can be read in one
sitting. Rather, it is one to savour over a period of time, think
about and return to when ideas have begun to meld into
understanding. Perhaps one of the most interesting themes of the
book is its well-researched background about Victorian science and
the gathering of fossils, the role of women in Victorian times and
Victorian funeral customs, including taking photos of the dead. The
reader is drawn into the lives of Faith and her mother, both
constrained by attitudes to women of the time. Faith desperately
wants to study natural science and to be recognised by her father,
but that is not something that is acceptable for girls living in
that time, while her mother is forced to act as the helpless lady,
needing a man's protection, to get any stability for her family. The
final chapter is a wonderful summary of the difficulties that Faith
will face, but the effect that her efforts could have on 'some later
girl'.
The idea of a Lie Tree is a compelling one, and the reader is
dragged along into the consequences and nastiness that result from
the lies that Faith feeds the tree in her efforts to find who has
murdered her father. She not only lies, but attempts to
scientifically and rationally analyse the physical and dream
evidence that she finds in order to work out the mystery. She is
helped along by Clay, whose photography skills not only let the
reader know about funeral customs, but also help to uncover the
truth.
Hardinge has an original voice and mature and intelligent readers
will find much to savour in The lie tree.
Pat Pledger