That's what I'd do by Jewel
Ill. Amy June Bates. Simon and Schuster, 2012. Hardback. ISBN:
9781442458130.
This is a beautifully illustrated piece, with the watercolor,
gouache, pencil and pastels illustrations lifting the rhyme, which
limps along as a story, not flowing very well, but comes into its
own as a song.
Mother and baby are pictured in beautiful environments, both indoor
and outdoor, with whimsical additions such as hearts, flowers and
animals. There are many butterflies to count within the pages, which
adds a nice touch, an extra visual focus for the child being read
to.
Described by the author as a devotional letter, the book certainly
reads that way, at times even a little over the top. I felt that
there were opportunities within the illustrations to be more
inclusive of diverse parenting practices - for example the mother
was pictured feeding the baby with a bottle - however there can be
no doubt of the love of the mother for her child in these
illustrations.
The content of the story itself is simple and time honoured - if I
was a painter, a carpenter, a rabbit, this is what I would do. The
mother in the story is clearly besotted with her child, and their
relationship which is played out on the pages is a very special one.
I would recommend this book for libraries frequented by new parents
of all kinds - there is much about this book which would appeal to
mothers in the first flush of baby love.
Freya Lucas