Second Chance Summer by Morgan Matson
Simon and Schuster, 2012.ISBN: 9781416990673.
(Age: 14+) Highly recommended. Second Chance Summer is Matson's
second book. Her first, Amy and Roger's Epic Detour, dealt with
serious issues in a mostly light-hearted way. This time she offers a
much more serious look at a topic that seems to be trending in YA
books this year: the cancer novel.
Much like John Green's lauded novel, The Fault in Our Stars,
Second Chance Summer steers away from sentimentality and cliche, and
the conclusion is devastating and confronting. However, instead of
the teenagers being the victims, in this book it is a parent who is
suffering.
The main character, Taylor's father, is diagnosed with pancreatic
cancer and given a poor prognosis. On the back of this news, the
family relocate to their lake house for the summer, a place they
have not visited for five years. Returning there is doubly traumatic
for Taylor. Clearly she must accept her father's chances, and on top
of that, the lake house is where she first fell in love. Henry
Crosby of course is now her next door neighbour, and for various
reasons it is awkward and confusing for both of them.
Matson doesn't rush this story. She doesn't skimp on details. While
the family crisis is dealt with in the present, Taylor's personal
dramas are provided through flashback as readers are slowly given
the reasons for the awkwardness between her and Henry. While these
are fairly predictable and minor, it is easy to understand why
Taylor behaved as she did. And their journey back to each other is
believable and enjoyable.
Dad's story, however, provides much of the heart of the novel. He
wants this chance to reconnect with his children, and there are some
very moving scenes as he tries to leave his family without too much
sadness and trauma. These serious issues-based YA novels are always
well received by mature readers, especially girls seeking something
akin to the books of Jodie Piccoult. Themes include grief and loss,
family relationships, death and dying, and friendship and romance.
Trish Buckley