Pie in the sky by Remy Lai
Walker Books, 2019. ISBN: 9781250314093. 384pp.
(Age: 9+) Recommended. Pie in the sky is the debut novel by
author/illustrator Remy Lai and will appeal to children who like
graphic novels and is a fantastic way to move from the graphic novel
genre into narrative fiction. The story revolves around Jingwen who
has moved from his home country to Australia with his mum and
'annoying brother' Yanghao. In Australia he struggles to make sense
of the language and schooling, while at home his mum is working long
hours and is rarely at home. As the story progresses the reader
learns that Jingwen's father has died prior to leaving his old home
and his grandparents have stayed behind as well to look after their
cake shop. The plan was for Jingwen's family to move to Australia
and open a cake shop called 'Pie in the sky', and as the story
progresses Jingwen enlists the help of his brother to bake the cakes
that he and his father had planned to sell, even though his mother
has forbidden him to use the oven when she is not at home.
This book is an engaging read although some children may find it
difficult to follow the story as it chops and changes between
graphic novel, illustration and written narrative that at times
feels repetitive and bogged down in unnecessary details. However,
the story allows children to think about the struggles of those who
are immigrating to a new country with 'alien' languages and
different customs and may inspire them to be kinder to those around
them, including their siblings.
Jingwen is a relatable character who will engage the younger reader
and will allow all readers to delve into the life of the main
character and the family surrounding him. The author also encourages
the reader to think about how the loss of a parent might affect them
and the ways that memories can be kept alive through repeated
activity, even when you have been forbidden to do so!
The addition of a cake recipe at the back is a fantastic addition as
the book focuses on the baking of cakes which leaves the reader with
the desire to taste the creations of Jingwen and his father. Teacher's
notes are available. Themes: Family, Migration, Graphic
novel/fiction hybrid, Grief, Cooking, Siblings.
Mhairi Alcorn