Nicholas Dane by Melvin Burgess
Puffin, 2010. ISBN 9780141316338.
(Ages 16+) Recommended. Melvin Burgess has always pushed the
boundaries in his writing. When he won the Carnegie medal for Junk
in
1996 it made headline news, hardly surprising as it represented such a
seismic shift in literature for young people. Subsequent novels also
roused strong opinions, and Nicholas Dane will be no exception.
Set in the 1980s this is the harrowing story of Nick whose mother dies
of a heroin overdose and who finds himself at the tender mercies of a
group of so called teachers (all inadequate, bullying torturers) at a
children's home. Burgess does not hold back. Details of child sex
abuse, the skewed and damaged thought processes of paedophiles, the
physical and emotional torture of children, drugs, prostitution and
armed robbery all figure in this compelling novel.
Melvin Burgess is a genius at painting pictures with words. (I still
shudder when I picture one of the characters in Junk cradling
her baby
while she injects heroin). This is an even tougher subject to write
about for young people, and the line between adult and young adult is
very hazy indeed. It is exceptionally well written; perhaps the only
way Burgess could successfully handle such horrific storylines was to
adopt a clinical almost documentary approach. Of course this factual
style simply serves as a reminder that this story is embedded in the
horrific experiences that real children endured at the hands of the so
called care system.
The trauma that Nick and his friends Oliver and Davy experience is hard
to believe. Nick is a tough character and Burgess does not dwell in
huge detail regarding the emotional cost of his abuse, but it's there
in his attempts to blot out the horror with drugs and alcohol and in
his total inability to build successful relationships. Oliver is
perhaps the most tragic character. Groomed by paedophiles since a young
age, he knows no other form of affection. The fact that he disappears
and Nick fails in his attempts to find him leaves the reader to draw
their own conclusions - lost in the care system, or murdered by
paedophiles? We never find out.
I urge caution in sharing this book with young people. This is HEAVY
reading, perhaps best adopted by a reading group, where the traumatic
events can be chewed over and discussed. I haven't read anything as
harrowing or deeply affecting since We Need to talk about Kevin,
but of
course that was written for adults.
Claire Larson