Magisterium: The Iron Trial by Cassandra Clare and Holly Black
Doubleday, 2014. ISBN 9780857532503.
(Ages: 11+) Themes: Magic, Family, Boarding Schools, Disability,
Orphans, Grief/Loss, Good v Evil. The Iron Trial is the
first book in a new series which will appeal to middle school
readers who love Harry Potter. Unfortunately, some reviewers are
already casting it in a negative light because of its similarity to
the Rowling books, however, it does have enough differences to make
it worth a read.
Callum Hunt is a broken boy. Physically, as a baby his leg was
twisted beyond repair, so now at 12, he limps and is considered weak
by his peers and his teachers. But there is also damage to his
psyche. He's been traumatised by his mother's death, which happened
at the same time as his leg was ruined. His father has raised him to
hide his magical ability, and even as he is about to sit for the
examination that will allow him to enter The Magisterium, he knows
his father's expectations - Cal must fail.
All this is set up in the first few chapters. It's clearly aimed at
middle graders, but since we know there is a plan for five books,
each one following Cal through a year at the school, we can predict
a couple of things: Cal will grow up and age, and developmentally so
too will his readers. And I am betting the books will progress into
darker territory.
There is a range of supporting characters, and we don't know who to
trust. The narrative moves at a reasonable pace. There are clues
left scattered so readers can foreshadow horrible masters, jealous
peers and potential love interests. Due to his impairment, Cal is
used to being treated badly and left alone. But he never uses his
limp as an excuse. He wants to be given the same opportunities as
everyone else, and it is gratifying to see him find some friends and
start to feel a part of a group.
There are a couple of unexpected, but welcome plot twists. They are
probably signposted a little too obviously, but for readers who
simply get caught up in the story, and don't question motives or
hints, the story does play out unpredictably.
Okay, back to Harry Potter. I know people bemoan how derivative some
books are, but I have to say I have kids in my library who still
call Harry their favourite read, and are searching out for something
similar. The Iron Trial might just fill that void.
I found it absorbing and tense, especially the concluding chapters.
Trisha Buckley