Lies, knives, and girls in red dresses by Ron Koertge
Ill. by Andrea Dezso. Candlewick, 2012. ISBN 9780763644062.
(Age: 16+) Recommended, but not for the faint hearted. Fairy tales
retold. Some adult themes.
Koertge has a funny, provoking retelling of 23 familiar and not so
familiar fairy tales, which are not for the faint hearted or for the
young. This excerpt from Bluebeard is a good example of the humour,
style and nature of his free verse:
Yes it's blue and Yes it tickles and Yes
he's had a lot of wives
and nobody knows what happened to them
but he's fun at the party and omigod
that castle!
Most of the fairy tales are about two pages in length, written in
free prose and often with controversial and adult themes. They are
illustrated by Andrea Dezso in thick black ink, often in horrifying
images, which bring another dimension to the story. An example of
this is The robber bridegroom which I was not familiar with.
A miller's daughter is engaged to a guy she barely knows and follows
him through the woods. There she is horrified to see him and his
friends argue about who gets to eat the toes of a dead girl.
Koertge's verse was satirical and very funny, and the bridegroom
gets his just deserts. The miller's daughter "finds men
untrustworthy now. She prefers to live alone and teach Feminist
Theory & Practice at the local community college." However,
after reading the story I went back to the pictures which show a
body being dismembered and are quite disturbing.
Once I started the book, I found that I had to continually return as
Koertge's satire and dark humour were very compelling. Modern
touches like parties, a GPS and the speech in Red Riding Hood,
Home at last, Tells her Mother what happened (Like, where to
even start. So, okay - at the beginning. Right.) make it relevant to
today's older teens.
There is controversial subject matter, like drugs, dismemberment and
sexual undertones, scattered throughout the book, and the humour and
unconventional nature of the subject matter would probably make it
perfect for the older reluctant reader, both male and female.
However it is not for everyone and school librarians should read it
first to make sure that it is suitable for the clientele in their
schools.
Pat Pledger