Five on a Treasure Island by Enid Blyton

This graphic retelling of the classic Enid Blyton tale is the first in the original series where the five meet. George’s father has decided to sell Kirrin Island as it will cost too much to fix up the ruins. Meanwhile the Five have discovered a treasure ship washed up after a storm and have to defend their find from the antique dealer who knows that there is likely to be Aztec gold buried there and has offered to buy the island. The Five have to find the gold before the criminals do, having exciting adventures along the way. The back story about the Ayacotl is a bit of a distraction and the plot is as improbable as in the original. There are some pretty scary male characters including George’s father who is easy to confuse with the other adult males in the story, not helped by the two “criminals” being twins! The 50’s colours, styling and characterisation is very reminiscent of Herge’s “Tintin” books and I found the mismatch a bit confusing.

This small, colourful retelling of the classic story will appeal to those familiar with the original series wanting to share with their grandchildren but this reduction to just 60 pages is unlikely to engage a new generation.

Themes: Adventure, Friendship, Treasure, Mystery.

Sue Speck