All too much by Jo Cotterill
Hopewell High series. Bloomsbury Education, 2017. ISBN
9781472934079
(Age: 12+) In this, the first of the Hopewell High series, we follow
the story of Samira. Sammy (as her friends all her) is an Iranian
student who has come to the UK to study. She has a great group of
friends who are all in the same year level, but she likes to study
and her friends are far too occupied with boys and mascara.
Though the girls spend most out of class time in The Nest (their
living quarters), there is room for more detail but the author
doesn't deliver. Also lacking is any recognition of what it must be
like to be an international student and teenager away from her
family in school - surely an underlying stressor in the midst of the
other goings-on.
In this High Interest Low Literacy novel, Sammy begins to feel the
pressure of being an A student and the embarrassment of her father
calling to find out how her French Test went. With a lot on her
plate already, Sammy is invited to join the quiz team and is excited
that she is the youngest student to be asked. As the pressure
builds, the novel begins to focus on Samira's coping strategies and
touches briefly on the subject of non-suicidal self-injury
(self-harming) and cutting. While Sammy learns different ways to
deal with her stress, this is not explicitly explored. Somehow it
seems too much like a blanket is thrown over the problem itself and
the solutions that seem to 'fix it' are unlikely to be a fix for
someone who is a chronic cutter or is more adept at hiding it. While
it covers the issue of cutting, there is no real resolution in
place.
Clare Thompson
Publisher's note: Bloomsbury High Low books encourage and support
reading practice by providing pacy, age-appropriate stories for
struggling and reluctant readers, those with dyslexia, or those with
English as an additional language. Printed on tinted paper and with
a dyslexia friendly font, they are aimed at readers aged 12+ and
have a manageable length (80 pages) and reading age (9+). They are
produced in association with reading experts at CatchUp, a UK
charity which aims to address underachievement caused by literacy
and numeracy difficulties.