Alex as well by Alyssa Brugman
Text, 2013. ISBN 9781922079237
(Ages: 12+) Recommended. Growing up. Sexuality. Now a teenager, Alex
feels more female than male, and refuses to take the medication
which suppresses his femininity. Born without specific gender
alignment, Alex has been brought up as a boy by sometimes caring but
often confused parents, but is determined to make his own decisions.
He leaves school where he has been bullied, and enrolls in another
school as a girl, wearing a dress and drawing her hair extensions
back into a pony tail. She is amazed at how differently she is
treated as a girl, and the underlying values attributed to one sex
over the other. It is fascinating to see Brugman playing around with
sex roles through this novel, exposing for us the different traits
credited to each gender through the body of the sometimes capricious
Alex.
But things do not go as she expects. Her new life is at odds with
the old, she is lonely and unsure of herself. She makes friends but
is attracted to one of the girls, while one of the boys is attracted
to her. Going to a solicitor to gain a new birth certificate telling
the world she is female, she makes her only friend, one who believes
her, explores the issues for her and protects her when her parents
become cloying.
It is the scenes with his parents that disturb. They come across as
totally confused, their relationship in tatters because of Alex and
their treatment of him, and they feel that life has treated them
unfairly. At times I wanted to yell at them, they never see Alex in
terms other than their failed male child, they never sit down with
her to talk things through, nor allow Alex to explain how she feels,
there is never a counsellor visited or doctor consulted, but the
internet and the rubbish advised by 'friends' seems to take
precedence, particularly where her mother is concerned.
I was enthralled with Alex's story, wanting her to make it in the
end, find her feet and make a stand. This she does, but in accepting
that her parents will never be wholly supportive she realises in the
end that we are all flawed, especially when it comes to gender and
what is expected of us.
Fran Knight