Review:
Hamlet by John Marsden
Text Publishing, 2008. ISBN 978192135147 1
(Ages: 12+) A modern version of the well known tale of Hamlet is sure
to raise eyebrows when the author tells us that he has made it more
accessible to an adolescent audience. Some will say it is dumbing it
down, but I found it to be better than that. Yes there is an element of
change for change's sake, and I was annoyed at the
sex scenes designed to titillate rather than further the plot, but
Marsden sticks to the storyline, while trying to expose the incredible
decisions Hamlet must make. Sometimes his attempts to translate
Shakespeare's language into a more palatable form, is clunky and
readers will notice the variation of style. Marsden includes some links
between the familiar scenes which draw out some of the possible reasons
behind peoples' actions which will make some events clearer for the
novice.
Hamlet and co are adolescent, Hamlet at boarding school in nearby
Gravatar when he hears of his father's death and mother's remarriage.
He lopes along, understandably trying to make sense of it all, but when
the ghost appears, he is torn. From playing football with Horatio, and
having lewd thoughts about Ophelia, he now must turn to graver actions.
He gives the players newly arrived at the castle, some extra lines to
say in their play and this serves to warn us all that dire deeds will
soon transpire.
When he next sees Ophelia, he is maddening in his response, when he
sees Gertrude he hears something behind the curtain, and stabs, killing
Polonius. Laertes then comes on the scene wanting revenge and Claudius
plots for Laertes and Hamlet to meet in a competition. The end is near
when Gertrude drinks the poisoned wine meant for Hamlet, Hamlet stabs
Laertes with the poisoned sword and is also wounded. Struggling towards
Claudius, Hamlet then stabs the king and dies.
And when is it set? The use of carriages and 'Your Royal Highness', and
the word lavatory mark it as nineteenth century, but when the butler
refuses to change around the furniture because it is not on the list of
things he does, I became confused. Sandwiches appear at Gertrude's
wedding, Hamlet and Horatio play a strange form of golf with racquets,
and talk of playing football on Saturday afternoons.
But perhaps I'm nit picking. Kids will enjoy the thrill of it all;
teachers will give it to kids as an introduction to the play; some
adults will read it to remind them of their schooldays, and some will
read it to find out how the author has remodeled the play to suit a
21st century audience. But many like me, will go back to the play,
eagerly wanting to reread the familiar and entrancing words.
Fran Knight
Home
© Pledger
Consulting, 2007