Review:
One beetle too many by Kathryn Laskey and Matthew Trueman
Candlewick
Press, 2008. ISBN 9780763614362
(Ages: 10+) This strange picture book, concerning the life of Charles
Darwin is neither one thing nor the other. Written in the form of a
wordy story, it purports to be a biography, presenting Darwin's early
life, culminating in the voyage of The Beagle in 1831. He
collected specimens from all over South America, filling the ship with
animal bones never seen before; shells collected from the tops of
mountains and finch skulls from the Galapagos Islands. He sometimes
came into conflict with the captain of the ship, over the ideas
developing in his remarkable brain, questioning the story of the ark
and the great flood of the Bible.
Back in England he spent many years, refining and developing his ideas
on how the animals of the world emerged. His first published book, his
journal of the voyage of The Beagle, appeared ion 1839, and his
tome which described the ideas he developed,
On the origin of
species,
finally appeared in 1859, with similar success as the journal, but
arousing much controversy. Laskey devotes much space to the idea
prevalent at the time, that god created the earth, man and the animals,
trying unsuccessfully to explain why Darwin's book was controversial.
So we have a biography/picture book, attempting to make Darwin's life
and ideas accessible to readers in junior primary school, but using a
text that is difficult to read and illustrated in such a way that
makes Darwin an eccentric cartoon character. The facts given in the
book are sound but if it is to be an information book, why not use the
marvelous techniques used by better non fiction publishers: time lines,
fact boxes, side panels, photographs etc. I missed that reinforcement
of information, and came away with just a story of a strange man who
did not discipline his children. People wanting information about
Darwin and his ideas will need to look further.
Fran Knight
Home
© Pledger
Consulting, 2007