Review:
Abela : the girl who saw lions by Berlie Doherty
Andersen
Press 2008
(Age 11+) Berlie Doherty hits the jackpot with this compelling story of
Abela's journey from Tanzania to Sheffield. It pulls no punches. We
follow Abela as she tries to care for her sick mother in a filthy bed
in a hospital devoid of medicine and doctors. After her mother's death
Abela is smuggled to England by her conniving uncle who is planning to
pass her off as his own daughter in the hope that this will give him
the right to return to England and join his English wife. But the plan
goes wrong and Abela finds herself alone in a strange country with her
uncle's cruel and mentally unstable wife. Her escape and journey
through the social services system is traumatic and offers no easy
answers or cosy solutions.
This is rightfully Abela's story and the other main character, Rosa,
plays a supporting role. Both girls are well portrayed. Rosa is a
typical teenager, growing up in Sheffield and interested in fashion and
ice skating and this makes the sharp contrasts between the lives of the
girls particularly effective. Abela and Rosa don't meet until the final
part of the book but when they do I felt a huge sense of relief that
Abela had found love and stability again.
Doherty does not avoid difficult issues such as the AIDs crisis in
Africa, the challenges of being a foster parent and the cruelty of
other children. However I have one serious reservation about this book.
Abela undergoes the ordeal of female circumcision and although this is
described fleetingly I feel it is a step too far in a book that will be
read primarily by eleven to fourteen year old girls. In fact the veiled
language and vague description will only confuse and frighten young
readers and make them demand to know what has actually happened to
Abela. Perhaps I am old fashioned, but I think children should be
protected from knowledge of this barbaric practice for as long as
possible.
Claire Larson
Home
© Pledger
Consulting, 2007