Review:
The Other Book by Philip Womack
Bloomsbury, London. 2008
(Age 10 – 14 years) Philip Womack explores the supernatural in
The
Other Book, a new fantasy for young readers. At boarding school
in modern-day England, twelve year old Edward Pollock discovers an old
book in the school library; it is cursed and waiting for an opportunity
to weld an evil magic after being lost for three hundred years.
After discovering the book, Edward gradually becomes more bewildered
and realises he must control some dark power which tries to overcome
him at every turn. His strength of character, and sense of duty
and trust are constantly tested. With the help of a knight who
appears mysteriously, Edward learns that the future of his world
depends on his ability to withstand the evil power at work.
Edward's story is a series of exciting confrontations with those who
wish to take the book back from this young 'carrier'. Lady Anne,
Mrs Phipps, Dr Spawforth and Reverend Smallwood oppose all moves by
Edward to restore its power. These are great characters and the
story rolls along very well. There is plenty of action as
Edward's courage is constantly tested; it seems that there is no one he
can trust.
For a first novel Womack successfully lures the reader into his
imagined world, and the array of characters weave a great story.
Numerous editorial errors are annoying and the language style is clumsy
at times but
The Other Book has a sound sense of place and time
and is
an absorbing read. This book is recommended for younger readers,
however, often the line which divides reality and the supernatural
becomes blurred and so some images are disturbing.
Julie Wells
Home
© Pledger
Consulting, 2007