The Mozart question by Michael Morpurgo
Walker Books, 2007.
(Ages 10+) Sent by her boss to interview the best violin player in the
world, Lesley is given one imperative command, not to ask the Mozart
question. At the violinist's house in Venice, Lesley is awkward and
tongue tied, unsure of how to start. The amazing Paolo Levi is in front
of her, a junior reporter given her first big assignment because of her
boss' skiing accident. Inadvertently she asks the question, totally
ignorant of its meaning, and because of her innocence, Paolo decides to
tell her.
Morpurgo has created an exceptional way to tell children of the horror
of the concentration camps in Europe during World War 2. Paolo tells
Lesley of his parents and the hidden violin. Seeing a violinist in the
streets, he learns to play the instrument, and when one day, he takes
the busker back to his home, to reveal to his parents his skill, the
three realise that they know each other. They were all violinists at a
camp, where they were forced to play in an orchestra while people were
killed in the gas chambers.
An emotional read, one that reinforces that a secret is just a lie,
tells of the camps and their horror through what happened to one
family, particularising the many images we see of the dead and dying at
these places. It is Morpurgo's gift that he can tell children of such
places with humour and a positive point of view, allowing children to
absorb what happened there. Foreman's illustrations stress the calm
nature of Venice and the pot of tea is repeated at the start and finish
of the book, drawing the reader into the familiar after reading about
this dreadful episode during war.
Fran Knight